Hall of Fame
Bill Bradley (Basketball) 1988

First Team
Jen Babik (Softball) 1994, 1995
Ken Beytin (Baseball) 1974
Bill Bradley (Basketball) 1965
Peter Callahan (Cross Country/Track & Field) 2013
Kevin Fox (Football) 1976
Kevin Guthrie (Football) 1982, 1983
*Joe McCarthy (Volleyball) 1997
Michelle Miller (Basketball) 2016
Kit Mueller (Basketball) 1991
*Susan Rea (Soccer) 1999
Julia Ratcliffe (Cross Country/Track & Field) 2015
Dick Sandler (Football) 1968
Alex Sierk (Football) 1998
*Josh Sims (Lacrosse) 2000
Stacy Thurber (Softball) 1995
*Justin Tortolani (Lacrosse) 1991, 1992
*Harald Winkmann (Fencing) 1994

Second Team
Cameron Atkinson (Football) 2002
Alex Banfich (Track & Field) 2012
*Jim Barlow (Soccer) 1991
*Steffany Bender (Softball) 1990
Sandi Bittler (Basketball) 1989, 1990
*Joy Bucher (Rowing) 2000
Bob Flaherty (Baseball) 1977
Steve Goodrich (Basketball) 1998
Barnes Hauptfuhrer (Basketball) 1976
Steve Hillegeist (Football) 1989
*Anne Lee (Softball) 1987
*Scott Reinhardt (Lacrosse) 1994
Anthony Riposta (Football) 1973
Bob Roma (Basketball) 1978
*Josh Sims (Lacrosse) 1999
Frank Sowinski (Basketball) 1977, 1978
Landis Stankievech (Ice Hockey) 2008
Stacy Thurber (Softball) 1994, 1996
Marc Washington (Football) 1996

Third Team
*Scott Anderson (Track & Field) 1996
Patrick Barba (Soccer) 2017
Megan Brandeland (Track & Field) 2009
*Lindsay Campbell (Fencing) 2002
Steven Cook (Basketball) 2017
*Grace Cornelius (Swimming & Diving) 1995
Dyan Dieda (Softball) 1992
Steph Fox (Softball) 1993
Brian Kappel (Baseball) 2005
Michelle Miller (Basketball) 2015
Kit Mueller (Basketball) 1990
David Nightingale (Track & Field), 2007
Thomas Pauly (Baseball) 2003
*Kristin Schwab (Field Hockey) 2009
Erin Snyder (Softball) 2006
Sean Sullivan (Baseball) 1992
August Wolf (Track & Field) 1983
Jonahan Yergler (Fencing) 2012

Honorable Mention
Gordon Enderle (Basketball) 1982

*At-Large Team Selection