Hall of Fame
Arne Duncan (Basketball) 2012
Angela Ruggiero (Ice Hockey) 2015

First Team
Melanie Baskind (Soccer) 2012
*Mark Benning (Ice Hockey) 1986
Brian Bergstrom (Football) 1984
Andrew Berry (Football) 2008, 2009
*Ed Boyda (Golf) 1997
Cameron Brate (Football) 2013
Joe Carrabino (Basketball) 1985
Arne Duncan (Basketball) 1987
Adabelle Ekechukwu (Cross Country/Track & Field) 2014
*Sheila Findley (Swimming & Diving) 1988
*John Friedman (Cross Country/Track & Field) 2002
Ben Green (Football) 1999
*Dora Gyorffy (Track & Field) 2000, 2001
Andrew Huling (Baseball) 1999
Marko Kostich (Volleyball) 2018
*J.P. O'Connor (Wrestling) 2010
Hana Peljto (Basketball) 2003, 2004
*Angela Ruggiero (Ice Hockey) 2004
Reka Cserny (Basketball) 2005
Alex White (Football) 2018

Second Team
Melanie Baskind (Soccer) 2011
John Bechdol (Football) 2005
Marie Becker (Soccer) 2018
*Mark Benning (Ice Hockey) 1987
Rebecca Christensen (Cross Country/Track & Field) 2009
*Julie Chu (Ice Hockey) 2007
Kevin Dulsky (Football) 1987
Jim Goffredo (Basketball) 2007
*Paul Gompers (Cross Country/Track & Field) 1987
Joseph Hiffa (Football) 1993
Tim Hill (Basketball) 1999
Will Johnson (Football) 2006
R.D. Kern (Football) 2001
*Tom Killian (Water Polo) 1991
*Jessica Larson (Women's Soccer) 1999
Tanner Lee (Football) 2018
Ellen Macadam (Softball) 2011
Joe Margolis (Football) 1982
*Tim Martin (Swimming & Diving) 2000
Spencer Neumann (Football) 1991
*Dana Remus (Rowing) 1997
Chris Smith (Football) 1997
Josh Staph (Football) 2002
*Emily Stauffer (Soccer) 1998
Matt Stehle (Basketball) 2006
*Jennie Strickler (Track & Field) 1983
Noah Van Niel (Football) 2008
Jim Villanueva (Football) 1983
*Paul Watson (Swimming) 1990

Third Team
Jane Alexander (Softball) 2012
*Melissa Anderson (Tennis) 2006
Tammy Butler (Basketball) 1995
*Greg Chang (Fencing) 1997
*Emily Cross (Fencing) 2006, 2008, 2009
Eli Dershwitz (Fencing) 2018
*Dov Grumet-Morris (Ice Hockey) 2005
Elissa Hart (Volleyball) 1997
Brett Henderson (Cross Country, Track & Field) 2017
Adrienne Jarocki (Fencing) 2017
*Bill Jones (Swimming & Diving) 2009
Natalie Larkin (Soccer) 2018
*James Lawler (Swimming & Diving) 2005
*Kunj Majmudar (Tennis) 1999
*Diane Marks (Rowing) 1999
*Katie McAnaney (Lacrosse) 1989
*Mike Mosca (Swimming & Diving) 2014, 2015
*Kirk Nielsen (Ice Hockey) 1996
*Kanu Okike (Lacrosse) 2001
Nikki Okwelogu (Cross Country, Track & Field) 2017
*Ed Pankau (Volleyball) 2000
*Joel Radtke (Golf) 1996
Amy Reinhard (Softball) 1995
*Howard Sands (Tennis) 1983
*Christine Shortsleeve (Lacrosse) 1997
*Brenda Taylor (Track & Field) 2001
*Jack Wylie (Golf) 1995

Fourth Team
Joe Carrabino (Basketball) 1981

Honorable Mention
Bobby Kay (Baseball) 1986

*At-Large Team Selection