Hall of Fame
Ken Dryden (Ice Hockey) 2005
Joseph Holland (Football) 1991
Ellen Mayer Sabik (Gymnastics) 1997

First Team
*John Bayne (Soccer) 1986, 1987, 1988
*Mitch Belisle (Lacrosse) 2007
Chico Bengochea (Baseball) 1979
Karen Chastain (Track & Field) 2001
*Jennifer Cobb (Track & Field) 1991, 1992
Graham Dow (Basketball) 2007
*Mark Fergeson (Wrestling) 1993
*Colin Greening (Ice Hockey) 2010
*Rachel Goldberg (Gymnastics) 2004
Derrick Harmon (Football) 1982, 1983
Joseph Holland (Football) 1977, 1978
Seth Hope (Football) 2018
Devin McMahon (Cross Country/Track & Field) 2014
*Matt McMonagle (Lacrosse) 2007
*Maddie Pearsall (Gymnastics) 2011
*Jaimee Reynolds (Lacrosse) 2001, 2002
Kevin Rooney (Football) 2004
*Ginny Ryan (Track & Field) 1995
*Ellen Mayer Sabik (Gymnastics) 1983, 1984
Emily Shearer (Cross Country/Track & Field) 2014
Luke Siwula (Football) 2007
*Marc Thorne (Soccer) 1997
Dave Van Metre (Football) 1985

Second Team
Chico Bengochea (Baseball) 1978
Eve Bishop (Cross Country/Track & Field) 2015
Nick Booker-Tandy (Football) 2012
Mike Cahill (Football) 1983
*Tim DeBois (Lacrosse) 2004
*Karen Feldman (Soccer) 1984
Grant Gellatly (Football) 2014
*Colin Greening (Ice Hockey) 2009
Seth Hope (Football) 2017
Alyson Inithar (Softball) 2010
*Olga Itskhoki (Tennis) 1996
Scott Kenney (Baseball) 1989
*David Key (Lacrosse) 2001
*David LeNeveu (Ice Hockey) 2003
Ron Mateo (Football) 1996
*Mark McRae (Ice Hockey) 2003
Gregory Myers (Baseball) 1981
*Scott Paltrowitz (Tennis) 2004
*Stephen Raab (Gymnastics) 1983
Luke Siwula (Football) 2008
Mark Smith (Baseball) 1987
*Casey Stevenson (Lacrosse) 2005
*Marc Thorne (Soccer) 1996
Mark Turley (Football) 1979
Dave Van Metre (Football) 1984
Ramon Watkins (Football) 1991

Third Team
Shonda Brown (Track & Field) 2005
Lenny Collins (Basketball) 2006
*Mark Fergeson (Wrestling) 1992
Jeff Gaca (Basketball) 1993
Stone Gettings (Basketball) 2018
*Rachel Goldberg (Gymnastics) 2002, 2003
*Troy Gorman (Lacrosse) 1999
Nick Huber (Track & Field) 2012
Scott Kenney (Baseball) 1988
*Mark McRae (Ice Hockey) 2002
Elise Menaker (Softball) 2010
*Meghan Miller (Gymnastics), 2005
Kelly Olino (Softball) 1999
*Stephen Raab (Gymnastics) 1984
*Ginny Ryan (Track & Field) 1994
Rudy Winkler (Cross Country, Track & Field) 2017
Chris Wroblewski (Basketball) 2011, 2012

Fifth Team
Peter Call (Basketball) 1978

Honorable Mention
*Lisa Stroud (Gymnastics) 1986

*At-Large Team Selection