First Team
Brian Chaput (Track & Field) 2004
Rich Comizio (Football) 1986
Katy Cross (Soccer) 2004
Katy Cross (Soccer) 2005
Michael Germino (Football) 1999
Doug Glanville (Baseball) 1991
Carol Kuna (Basketball) 1980
Elisabeth Kwan-Hefferan (Volleyball) 2004
Robert Morse (Basketball) 1972
*Tom Pereles (Swimming) 1985
Andrei Rodzianko (Wrestling) 1999

Second Team
John Bishop (Football) 1997
Ed Boone (Baseball) 1974
Brian Chaput (Track & Field) 2003
James Fangmeyer (Football) 1986
Tom Gilmore (Football) 1985
Mike Hall (Track & Field) 2008
Ed Haughey (Baseball) 1995
Elisabeth Kwak-Hefferan (Volleyball) 2002
*Bettie Lombardi (Lacrosse) 1983
Andy Muhlstock (Baseball) 1973

Third Team
Jesse Carlin (Track & Field) 2008
Omid Shokoufandeh (Soccer) 2009

*At-Large Team Selection